Slice:
President Bush said on Monday that schools should teach "intelligent design," a theory asserting that an intelligent agent helped shape the origins and history of the earth and life, in addition to evolution, the theory of life that enjoys overwhelming support from scientists.Mr. Bush, who spoke in an interview with reporters from five Texas newspapers, said students should learn about intelligent design to understand the debate over creation-of-life theories. His support could help the efforts of Christian conservatives who have pushed for public schools to teach the theory.
"I think that part of education is to expose people to different schools of thought," Mr. Bush told the reporters. "You're asking me whether or not people ought to be exposed to different ideas, the answer is yes."
Intelligent-design theory holds that some biological systems are so complex that they could have arisen only through the action of an intelligent force -- ostensibly divine -- and not simply through Darwinian evolution.
5 comments:
I think both theories are backed by faith.
No, Intelligent Design is a new word for "creationism", has no scientific evidence whatsoever to back it up, cannot be proven or disproven by definition, and is therefore entirely based on faith and not scientific at all.
Evolution, on the other hand, has evidence to back it up (SCIENTIFIC evidence of evolution exists everywhere), it can in fact be proven using scientific methods, and has the backing of the scientific community at large. It is therefore, not based on faith (unless you consider believing in science to be faith, which would be pretty stupid).
Intelligent design is just a new name for an old idea. It teaches a religious foundation for the creation of life on earth, and as such has no business whatsoever in our public schools. If parents want their kids to know about intelligent design, they can teach their kids THEMSELVES (oh what a concept), or SEND THEM TO PRIVATE SCHOOL.
Once you introduce religious teachings in public schools, you have to teach EVERY religious teaching, and this is downright impossible.
I think both theories are backed by faith.
No, Intelligent Design is a new word for "creationism", has no scientific evidence whatsoever to back it up, cannot be proven or disproven by definition, and is therefore entirely based on faith and not scientific at all.
Evolution, on the other hand, has evidence to back it up (SCIENTIFIC evidence of evolution exists everywhere), it can in fact be proven using scientific methods, and has the backing of the scientific community at large. It is therefore, not based on faith (unless you consider believing in science to be faith, which would be pretty stupid).
Intelligent design is just a new name for an old idea. It teaches a religious foundation for the creation of life on earth, and as such has no business whatsoever in our public schools. If parents want their kids to know about intelligent design, they can teach their kids THEMSELVES (oh what a concept), or SEND THEM TO PRIVATE SCHOOL.
Once you introduce religious teachings in public schools, you have to teach EVERY religious teaching, and this is downright impossible.
Yes, evolution is backed by scientific research, not by faith. Those religoids who use the catchphrases about the "theory" of evolution are unaware of contemporary science. Evolution was a theory a hundred years ago. It was moved from theory to proven fact years ago. It does not threaten religion in any way. Why are they so afraid of it? And why do they keep trying to portray their mythology as science? What is this, the 13th century or something!?
I suppose Bush means everyone BUT him needs to be exposed to different ideas.
All this coming from Bush is kind of laughable, given his explanation.
rcoley, heads up!
100 scientists think ''intelligent design'' is an alternative to evolution?
100 scientists probably think smoking is good for you. 100 scientists probably think it's a good idea to fly planeloads of passengers into tall buildings. Should these alternatives to the conventional view be taught in school?
Post a Comment